Max Thill and I (Donald Farnsworth, aka Aldo) are investigating flaws and distinctive features in early European handmade papers for an upcoming edition (40 volumes). The book will consist of handmade examples of each flaw, along with an explanation of what the flaw is and how it was made, all bound together.
We think of this project as forensic papermaking: studying old sheets, looking for clues, unlearning some of our good papermaking habits, and trying to recreate what we have seen in the sorting room, the beater room, at the vat, on the mould and felts, in the press, the sizing tub, and in the drying loft.
If you recognize any of these features, have thoughts about how they may have been created, or happen to have a collection of old paper that includes a sheet with a particularly interesting or fantastic feature, we would love to hear from you.
All photographs are with transmitted light unless otherwise noted.
Measurements shown are in centimeters.
Click to enlarge.
Unknown flaw #1: More than just an air bubble (blister)
Unknown flaw #2: Possibly a dragged felt
Unknown flaw #3: Update: Suspected "crushing." Fissures, possibly caused by excessive pressure on an overly wet couch, perhaps with slow-draining furnish. Notice what may be finger marks.
Unknown flaw #4: Update: We now think this flaw is caused by wet furnish, a hard, wet, misaligned felt, and excessive couch pressure. Tentatively calling this flaw cumuli or cumulus
Unknown flaw #5: lighter slanted stripes, along with air bubbles and other wild features
Unknown flaw #6: A wove sheet. Update: Cathy Baker suspects this is a tunnel —long air bubbles. Previously, we postulated percussion: A dropped mould edge on the top sheet of the post? Or a wave of furnish rising from under the mould during formation, lifting the sheet between rib(s) or wooden slats of the take-up reel, damaging the first few meters of damp paper on the paper machine?
Unknown flaw #7: Update: Cathy Baker suspects this is a tunnel —long air bubbles. Flaw on a matching wove sheet as flaw #6
Unknown flaw #8: A percussive (?) flaw on a printed antique laid paper
Unknown flaw #9: Update: Cathy Baker: "may have been made on a cylinder machine and perhaps due to a 'stuttering' cylinder." Wove likely machine-made sheet.
Unknown flaw #10: an unusual chain-line flaw
Unknown flaw #11: A wove sheet with a 'dribble' pattern. Drips while the sheet is drying?
Unknown flaw #11 & 13 This drip- or dribble-like light patch is similar to flaws 10 & 11, but it appears on an antique laid sheet rather than a wove sheet.
Unknown flaw #13 Very similar to flaw #11 & 12: but isolated to one corner of the sheet. Drips while the sheet is drying?
Unknown flaw #14, does not appear to be later damage
Unknown flaw #15: Very regular horizontal pattern in addition to shadow-lines on antique laid paper
Unknown feature #16: Notice double chain lines. Despite being previously laminated to another sheet and board, this appears to be a single sheet (i.e. not two sheets laminated). Do such moulds still exist? (Note: measurement is in inches for this sheet)
Unknown flaw #17: Unusual mottling. Foam of some kind? We have not been able to reproduce this effect with foam from gelatin, starch, or soap
Unknown flaw #18: Odd air bubbles (blisters) or something else?
Unknown flaw #19 on right border
Thin edge, drops, and a heavy pulp inclusion
Cloudy sheet with crushing marks
Damaged laid lines and a vatman's tear
Stitched together, woven screen (machine wire or forming fabric) on a paper machine?
Another example of non-aligned offset rib shadows due to a laid screen made on a loom, causing offset shadow lines
Watermark flaw (with coucher's tear)
Finger Marks/Handling flaw on lower left corner
Slurred chain lines and thin across the "bad side" of the sheet (across the bottom - caused by a clogged screen). At The Paper Foundation, Kendal, UK
Abrasion upper left, blurred chain lines, and thin across the "bad side" of the sheet. At The Paper Foundation, Kendal, UK
Stuck together during sizing, torn apart, leaving the double layers where stuck. Then printed.
Old sheet in raking light with knots, shives, and back mark.
Old sheet with Knots & Shives
Surface abrasion by coucher?
Double chain lines
Burnisher streaks
Prominent back mark in gutter
A lovely example of a crushed couch: pressing too hard at the vulnerable beginning or end of the couch, causing stretch marks. Also notice the tranchefile line clearly along the left edge. Thank you, Cathy Baker, for pointing it out.
Magnolia paper: samples of successful recreations, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Knots, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Cloudy, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Slurred Chain Lines, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Slumping (when leaned on the ass/asp/horn too soon), flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Vatman's Drops (tears), flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Coucher's Drop (tear), flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Felt Hair Marks, flax & hemp, in raking light
Magnolia paper: Old laid mould with missing laid lines, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Modern Laid, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Heavy Surface Laid Texture, raking light
Magnolia paper: Damaged when wet with size, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Back Mark, flax, and hemp
Magnolia paper: Air Bubble (blister), flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Non-Cellulose Additives, wool, silk, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Cumulus pattern. Suspected uneven moisture on felt. Fax and hemp furnish
Magnolia paper: Percussion while on post, flax, and hemp furnish
Magnolia paper: Rope Falling on Top Sheet of Post, flax, and hemp
Magnolia paper: Shives, flax & hemp
Magnolia paper: Water path from uneven moisture on felt or disrupted sheet after couching. Flax and hemp furnish
Magnolia paper: Felt Dragging on Top Sheet of Post, flax and hemp
Aldo with papermaker Tom Frith-Powell at The Paper Foundation
Magnolia Paper Studio:Noble & Wood Beater
Magnolia Paper Studio: Max taking down sized sheets from the treble lines
Magnolia Paper Studio: Max couching and Aldo (aka Don) at the vat
Magnolia Paper Studio: Tilting the mould on the ass too soon after formation
Magnolia Paper Studio: Dragging a felt to make drag marks on a newly couched sheet
Magnolia Paper Studio: Air bubbles or blisters
Magnolia Paper Studio: Couching improperly on a curve to make slurred chain lines
Magnolia Paper Studio: Attempting to make a percussion mark on a sheet by dropping the mould edge onto a felt-covered sheet
Magnolia Paper Studio: Inspecting a sheet riddled with knots
Magnolia Paper Studio: Allowing a newly gelatin-sized sheet to stick to itself. When dry, it must be torn off the horsehair rope.
Magnolia Paper Studio: Performing a Cobb test on heavily gelatin-sized paper
Magnolia Paper Studio: Cloudy sheets on the moulds
Magnolia Paper Studio: Attempting to create a flaw caused by sloppy rinsing of the mould
Magnolia Paper Studio: Half-rinsed sheet about to be second-dipped
Magnolia Paper Studio: Using a slice to lift a damp sheet
Magnolia Paper Studio: Max hanging sheets on horsehair rope, treble lines.
